Antonio de Montesinos’s sermon
In this entry · 3 sections
21 December 1511 · Santo Domingo, Hispaniola
It is the fourth Sunday of Advent, 21 December 1511, in the church of Santo Domingo, on Hispaniola. The island’s leading settlers, among them Governor Diego Columbus, are gathered to hear the sermon of the Dominican friar Antonio de Montesinos, who has announced that he will deal with a matter of general interest.
Montesinos, speaking on behalf of the island’s small Dominican community, which had discussed the text with its superior, Pedro de Córdoba, begins with a biblical quotation, “I am the voice of one crying in the wilderness”, and asks the encomenderos harshly by what right and by what justice they hold those Indians in such cruel servitude. According to Las Casas, the sermon had been written and signed by all the friars of the community. [B16]¶ [B16]¶
Montesinos denounces from the pulpit the abuses committed against the Indigenous people. He speaks on behalf of the Dominican community of Hispaniola. His sermon is known through Las Casas’s account: the transmitted testimony should be distinguished from an autograph manuscript of the preacher. [B349]
The settlers protested to the friars, and the sermon reached the court, where it helped open the debate that would lead, a year later, to the Laws of Burgos.
Why it matters
Introduces contemporary criticism of colonial exploitation.

Send comments to the author
Found an error or have information to contribute? Write privately to the author.