Valladolid controversy, 1550–1551

In this entry · 3 sections
  1. Why it matters
  2. Linked people
  3. Sources for this milestone

1550 · Valladolid

See the year 1550

It is the year 1550. For years, in Spain, the conquest of America has been debated passionately. A board of theologians and jurists meets in Valladolid to debate how conquests should be carried out, if they should be at all. The sessions run from 1550 into 1551. [B365]

Two positions face each other before the board. One is that of Friar Bartolomé de las Casas, who has spent decades in the Indies and tirelessly denounces the abuses against Indigenous people. The other is that of Juan Ginés de Sepúlveda, humanist and chronicler of the emperor, who argues that war against peoples considered barbarous can be just.

Las Casas and Sepúlveda hold opposing positions on war against the American peoples and Christian preaching. The board discusses legal and theological arguments; it should not be presented as a trial that declared Indigenous people human for the first time nor as an abolition of the conquest. [B365]

The theologian Domingo de Soto drew up a summary of the arguments, which Las Casas later published as the centrepiece of the «dispute or controversy». [B365] The discussion did not end with the board: Las Casas reworked his Replies to Sepúlveda, printed in Seville on 10 September 1552. [B365] The conquests went on, and the debate left an important body of arguments about the rights of the American peoples.

Why it matters

Places contemporary controversies without assigning them a simplified outcome.

Linked people

Sources for this milestone