Narváez: fleet, overland march and survivors
In this entry · 4 sections
Why do the numbers of men and vessels change during the narrative?
This supplement reviewed: · Siglo XVI
What the documents say
| Attributed account | Passages and locators |
|---|---|
Cabeza de Vaca estimates about six hundred men at departure in 1527, but speaks of three hundred on the overland march of 1 May 1528. |
|
Chapter VIII explains the building of boats after the overland hardships; these are not the ships that left Spain. | |
Chapter XVII relates the reunion with Dorantes and Castillo. Chapter XXVI distinguishes peoples and languages along the route. | |
In chapter XXXIV the narrator denounces other Spaniards’ attack on Indigenous people whom he had assured of peace. In chapter XXXVIII he acknowledges information obtained after the events. |
|
Chapter XXXVII separates Cabeza de Vaca’s return from that of Dorantes, who remains on another vessel. |
Editorial interpretation of the comparison
These headcounts belong to different stages; they should not be added or compared as simultaneous censuses. The book combines personal experience, reports from others and a defence of its author’s conduct. Its descriptions of Indigenous peoples require critical reading.
Scope and limitations of this review
The 1749 Barcia file contains two renderings of the same text, one replacing the long s. They are not independent testimonies.

Send comments to the author
Found an error or have information to contribute? Write privately to the author.