Definitive founding of Buenos Aires
In this entry · 11 sections
Episode · 1580. Juan de Garay.
Buenos Aires’s historical calendar dates its second foundation to 11 June 1580, linking it to Juan de Garay and departure from Asunción. It is distinguished from Pedro de Mendoza’s 1536 establishment, recounted by Schmidel. [B205] [B73]¶
Schmidel’s narrative allows a return to the first settlement and its difficulties, rather than turning the two foundations into continuous urban occupation. His testimony belongs to Mendoza’s enterprise and does not by itself establish Garay’s acts in 1580. [B73]¶
Second foundation designates a new colonial establishment. The references connect the two episodes without treating 1580 as the beginning of human presence in the estuary. [B205] [B73]¶
Context
Río de la Plata expansion was organized downriver from already formed colonial centers. The territory kept Indigenous populations and uses that did not depend on Spanish founding.
Development
The enterprise left Asunción and constituted the new center in June 1580. [B205]
A town council, allocation of space and relations with the surroundings were organized.
Events of this expedition
Outcome
The new city had continuity, but its history is not the uninterrupted survival of the 1536 settlement.
Limits of the evidence
The traditional title “definitive” describes colonial and urban continuity; it does not mean that the territory ceased to have conflicts.
Expedition facts
| Date | 1580 |
|---|---|
| Leader | Juan de Garay |
| Departure | Not specified in this entry |
| Destination | — |
| Period | 1580 |
People and societies
- Juan de Garay: Head of the enterprise from Asunción
Related people
Art and memory
- Portrait of Juan de Garay · Date not established
- Founding of Buenos Aires · 1923, second version
Sources and references
- [B205] Calendario histórico: junio. Gobierno de la Ciudad de Buenos Aires. s. f.; recurso institucional. Original record
- [B97] Ulrich Schmidl's Voyage to the Río de la Plata in Samuel Lafone Quevedo's translation (1903). Icíar Alonso Araguás. 2013 study of the 1903 translation of a 16th-century account. Original record
- [B73] The Conquest of the River Plate (1535–1555). Ulrico Schmidl y Álvar Núñez Cabeza de Vaca; edición de Luis L. Domínguez. Hakluyt Society edition (1891). Original record
- The first Buenos Aires and its abandonment. Gobierno de la Ciudad de Buenos Aires. It places the first settlement in February 1536 and distinguishes its abandonment from Garay's founding of 1580.
Documents and call numbers
- BUENOS_AIRES,1 · Record of the founding of Buenos Aires
General bibliography guides further reading; it is not a pinpoint reference for every claim. Page, chapter and archival references are identified at the relevant passages.
Further reading and comparison
- Union of the Crowns · 1580

Send comments to the author
Found an error or have information to contribute? Write privately to the author.