Juan de Garay
In this entry · 11 sections
A central figure in the second foundation of Buenos Aires, whose charter is dated 11 June 1580. The new settlement was established near Pedro de Mendoza’s earlier site. [B400] [B400]
Birth: Around 1528; Orduña and Villalba de Losa are disputed proposals [B400]. Death: Río de la Plata, 1583 according to Cava Mesa [B400].
Uncertain origin
Cava Mesa places birth around 1528 and distinguishes the proposed locations of Orduña and Villalba de Losa without treating his parents’ names as established. She describes travel with the family of judge Pedro Ortiz de Zárate and arrival at Sanlúcar in November 1543 to embark. Approximate ages in the account are not converted into an exact birth date. [B400]
From Peru to the Río de la Plata
The study places Garay in Lima with Ortiz de Zárate’s family and later in enterprises in Charcas, Santa Cruz and Paraguay. It attributes participation with Nufrio de Chaves in Santa Cruz de la Sierra’s 1561 foundation. For the Santa Fe mission it explains the objective of connecting Asunción through the Paraná to the sea and Spain. This remains Cava Mesa’s reconstruction rather than grounds for complete undescribed itineraries. [B400]
Santa Fe and Buenos Aires
Cava Mesa dates Santa Fe’s legal foundation to 15 November 1573 and confirmation of Garay as lieutenant governor, captain general and chief justice by Torres de Vera to 1578. For Buenos Aires the city government’s calendar dates foundation to 11 June 1580, distinguishing Trinidad as the city’s name and Santa María de los Buenos Ayres as the port’s. This section is used to compare Cava Mesa’s paragraph, which mistakenly inserts the name Francisco and the month January. [B205] [B400]
Death
Cava Mesa dates his last letter to Philip II to 9 March 1583 and describes the journey to guide Alonso de Sotomayor towards Chile. She places his death and those of twelve companions in an ambush near the former Sancti Spíritus fort, attributing the attack to Guaraní people. That identification remains attributed to the study; direct examination of a contemporary report of the attack is not claimed. [B400]
Offices
Chronology
A life, step by step. Follow the dates and open each milestone or image to explore its sources.
- Hacia 1528

Date not established About this image
Portrait of Juan de Garay · Date not established. Context portrait; it does not depict this event. Representation attributed to this person in the provenance record. It is not treated as evidence of physical appearance or as a record of their expeditions. The date of the work is distinguished from its digitisation date. The date of the work has not been established; the file upload date is not used to date the portrait.Approximate birth. [B400]
Explore this year - 1543
Preparations to embark with Ortiz de Zárate. [B400]
Explore this year - 1561
Santa Cruz de la Sierra according to Cava Mesa. [B400]
Explore this year - 1573
Foundation of Santa Fe. [B400]
Explore this year - 1578
Confirmation of offices. [B400]
Explore this year - 1580

Image linked to the milestone About this image
Founding of Buenos Aires, José Moreno Carbonero, 1910.Foundation of Trinidad and Buenos Aires port on 11 June. [B205]
View the milestone: Second founding of Buenos Aires - 1583
Death during Sotomayor’s journey. [B400]
Explore this year
Disputed dates and open questions
- Hypotheses about birth and parents are not presented as verified vital records. [B400]
Participation
- Definitive founding of Buenos Aires (1580): Head of the enterprise from Asunción
Mentioned in other entries
Una mención permite investigar una relación; no implica participación en la expedición ni acredita por sí sola el pasaje citado.
Sources
- Juan de Garay, Begoña Cava Mesa
- Carta del Consejo de Indias a Pedro de Mendoza sobre el Río de la Plata, Council of the Indies · Archivo General de Indias, PARES
- Calendario histórico: junio, Gobierno de la Ciudad de Buenos Aires
- Viaje al Río de la Plata de Ulrich Schmidel en traducción de Samuel Lafone Quevedo (1903), Icíar Alonso Araguás
Linked sources
- [B97] Ulrich Schmidl's Voyage to the Río de la Plata in Samuel Lafone Quevedo's translation (1903)
- [B205] Calendario histórico: junio
- [B400] Juan de Garay

Send comments to the author
Found an error or have information to contribute? Write privately to the author.