Urdaneta's discovery of the return route (tornaviaje)

In this entry · 19 sections
  1. Context
  2. Stages
  3. Events of this expedition
  4. Route data
  5. Outcome
  6. Limits of the evidence
  7. Expedition facts
  8. Organisation
  9. Objectives
  10. Encounters and societies
  11. Ships and crew
  12. People and societies
  13. Related people
  14. Related cartography
  15. Art and memory
  16. Other expeditions with shared protagonists
  17. Sources and references
  18. Further reading and comparison
  19. Sources of the related expeditions

Episode · 1565. Andres de Urdaneta.

On 1 June 1565 the ship San Pedro leaves Cebu bound for New Spain. The problem was known: since Magellan the Spaniards knew how to go to Asia across the Pacific with the winds behind them, but returning against them was another matter. Several attempts, among them Saavedra’s, had failed. Legazpi’s campaign started from that accumulated experience. [B52] [B105]

Urdaneta, an Augustinian friar who had survived the Loaísa expedition, designs a route across the North Pacific: go up to high latitudes, near 40° north, to find westerly winds, and then come down toward the American coast. The crossing lasts more than four months, amid sickness and deaths. In October the ship reaches the coast of New Spain and continues to Acapulco. [B100] [B105]

The tornaviaje made possible the connection that would sustain trans-Pacific trade. The organisation of the Manila galleon was a later development, not a fully constituted institution when leaving Cebu. [B105]

Arellano and Lope Martín’s San Lucas had returned earlier. Morga records that precedence but expresses an adverse judgment that must not be confused with the fact of the return. [B27]

The log extract reproduced by Sierra dates passing Navidad to 1 October and arrival at Acapulco to the 8th. The study’s statement on the following page giving the 1st for Acapulco does not match that extract; the discrepancy is retained. [B100]

Context

The main difficulty was not just crossing to Asia but returning east. Winds and currents forced a search for latitudes different from the outbound route. The campaign built on accumulated experience and earlier attempts, including Saavedra's. [B105] [B105]

Stages

Events of this expedition

Route data

Outcome

The tornaviaje made possible the connection that would sustain trans-Pacific trade. [B105]

Cuesta’s biography relates this return to the later Manila galleon route; the 1565 crossing is distinguished from its commercial development. [B105]

Limits of the evidence

Alonso de Arellano's return in 1565 must be distinguished from the route, documentation and continuity associated with Urdaneta. [B27] [B100]

The map's line is a schematic and not a day-by-day reconstruction of the ship's position.

Expedition facts

Date1565
LeaderAndres de Urdaneta
DepartureNot specified in this entry
Destination—
Period1565

Organisation

The San Pedro left Cebu on 1 June 1565. Felipe de Salcedo held command of the ship and Urdaneta played a decisive role in the navigation; government of the fleet and piloting are not confused. [B52] [B52]

Objectives

Encounters and societies

Cuesta describes illness and crew exhaustion. The extract reproduced by Sierra counts sixteen dead and eighteen men able to work when passing Navidad. [B105] [B100]

Ships and crew

ShipCaptainMasterPilotReference
San PedroFelipe de SalcedoMartín de IbarraEsteban Rodríguez and Rodrigo de EspinosaSpanish Geographical Society: composition of the San Pedro on the tornaviaje of 1565 [B165]

San Pedro: Andrés de Urdaneta directed the navigation as cosmographer. Ibarra and Esteban Rodríguez died before the arrival at Acapulco; these posts are not confused with those of the outbound voyage of 1564.

People and societies

Related people

Related cartography

Universale descrittione di tutta la terra conosciuta fin qui. 1565. Paolo Forlani; engraving by Ferrando Bertelli. Library of Congress. Provenance of the reproduction indicated in its link.
Select the image to open the full-size reproduction.

Universale descrittione di tutta la terra conosciuta fin qui · 1565. The continental shapes and the hypothetical southern land belong to the cartography of the time. The presence of a place does not prove a visit by the selected expedition.

Asiae nova descriptio · Copy of 1579, based on the author's earlier cartography. The record dates the copy to 1579. Luzon does not appear and several geographic shapes are distorted: its usefulness is to compare the knowledge of the period.

Maris Pacifici · 1589. The ship Victoria recalls the circumnavigation, but does not make the map a layout of the route of 1519–1522. The date of the map must be distinguished from that of the voyage.

Indiae Orientalis, insularumque adiacentium typus · Copy of the Latin edition of 1603; plate first published in 1570. The image is of 1603, not of the first edition of 1570. It does not describe Urdaneta's tornaviaje nor Mendaña's complete routes.

Art and memory

Other expeditions with shared protagonists

Sources and references

Documents and call numbers

General bibliography guides further reading; it is not a pinpoint reference for every claim. Page, chapter and archival references are identified at the relevant passages.

Further reading and comparison

See the year 1565

Sources of the related expeditions

Explore the interactive view