Mutiny at San Julián

In this entry · 5 sections
  1. Context
  2. Why it matters
  3. Where it appears
  4. Linked people
  5. Sources for this milestone

April 1520 · San Julián, Patagonia

See the year 1520

It is the night of 1 April 1520, Palm Sunday, in the bay of San Julián. Magellan’s fleet wintered there, and tiredness, hunger and mistrust of the Portuguese captain had been building tension. According to Pigafetta, the captains Juan de Cartagena, Gaspar de Quesada and Luis de Mendoza, together with Antonio de Coca, conspire against the captain general. [B23]

The mutineers seize three of the five ships, the San Antonio, the Concepción and the Victoria, and ask Magellan to change his way of commanding. Magellan reacts quickly. He sends a boat with trusted men, among them the constable Gonzalo Gómez de Espinosa, who recover the Victoria and kill Mendoza.

During the winter, several captains rebel against Magellan. The recovery of the Victoria, in which Gonzalo Gómez de Espinosa takes part, allows command to be restored. The executions and abandonments that follow show that discipline is imposed through violence, not through the consensus of the whole fleet. [B23]

According to Pigafetta, the treasurer Mendoza was stabbed to death and quartered, and Quesada was beheaded and quartered. Cartagena, after another attempt at rebellion, was banished in Patagonia with a priest: Magellan would not execute him because the emperor had made him captain of one of the ships. Others, pardoned, will follow the expedition to the end. [B23]

Context

First Circumnavigation: The Magellan–Elcano Expedition

Fleet meant to reach the Moluccas by the west. After Magellan's death, different leaders continued the campaign; the Victoria, commanded by Elcano on the return, completed the first documented circumnavigation. [B23]

The demand for spices and the dispute with Portugal drove a western route. The Castilian Crown authorized and organized the enterprise, supported by contracting networks and a crew of diverse origins. [B48] [B23]

The Trinidad repaired frames and keel in Tidore with local assistance before departing into the Pacific on 6 April 1522. The IHCN reconstruction follows Espinosa’s attempt separately from the Victoria’s return. [B47]

The Cochin letter is dated 12 January 1525 and bears the reference INDIFERENTE,1528,N.2: 1528 identifies the archival bundle, not the year of writing. The PARES summary places the return to the Moluccas after seven months at sea and records fourteen islands, tentatively associated there with Palau. It does not establish fourteen certain modern island identifications. [B42]

Why it matters

Documents a decisive command crisis before the passage into the Pacific.

Where it appears

Expeditions and episodes

Other milestones of those expeditions

Also mentioned in

Maps

Art

Linked people

Sources for this milestone